Compare commits

...

2 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Bokuan Li
4fb16feb5a Added the Arens extension.
Some checks failed
Compile Project / Compile (push) Failing after 43s
2026-08-13 14:27:43 -04:00
Bokuan Li
22a8d18845 Added trolling. 2026-08-12 22:40:04 -04:00
5 changed files with 197 additions and 1 deletions

View File

@@ -268,4 +268,18 @@
year = {2002}, year = {2002},
isbn = {978-1-85233-437-6}, isbn = {978-1-85233-437-6},
doi = {10.1007/978-1-4471-3903-4} doi = {10.1007/978-1-4471-3903-4}
} }
@article{ArensBilinear,
ISSN = {00029939, 10886826},
URL = {http://www.jstor.org/stable/2031695},
author = {Richard Arens},
journal = {Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society},
number = {6},
pages = {839--848},
publisher = {American Mathematical Society},
title = {The Adjoint of a Bilinear Operation},
urldate = {2026-08-13},
volume = {2},
year = {1951}
}

117
src/fa/norm/arens.tex Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,117 @@
\section{The Arens Product}
\label{section:arens-product}
\begin{definition}[Arens Extension]
\label{definition:arens-product}
Let $E, F, G$ be normed vector spaces over $K \in \RC$ and $\lambda \in L^2(E, F; G)$ be a continuous bilinear mapping, then there exists a unique bilinear mapping $\Lambda_1: E^{**} \times F^{**} \to G^{**}$ such that:
\begin{enumerate}
\item For each $(x, y) \in E \times F$, $\Lambda_1(x, y) = \lambda(x, y)$.
\item For each $x \in E$, $\Lambda_1(x, \cdot)$ is weak*-continuous.
\item For each $y \in F^{**}$, $\Lambda_1(\cdot, y)$ is weak*-continuous.
\end{enumerate}
Similarly, there exists a unique bilinear mapping $\Lambda_2: E^{**} \times F^{**} \to G^{**}$ such that:
\begin{enumerate}
\item For each $(x, y) \in E \times F$, $\Lambda_2(x, y) = \lambda(x, y)$.
\item[(2')] For each $x \in E^{**}$, $\Lambda_2(x, \cdot)$ is weak*-continuous.
\item[(3')] For each $y \in F$, $\Lambda_2(\cdot, y)$ is weak*-continuous.
\end{enumerate}
The mappings $\Lambda_1, \Lambda_2: E^{**} \times F^{**} \to G^{**}$ are the \textbf{first} and \textbf{second} \textbf{Arens extensions} of $\lambda$, respectively.
\end{definition}
\begin{proof}[Proof, {{\cite[Section 1, Theorem 3.2]{ArensBilinear}}}. ]
For each $x \in E$, the mapping $\lambda(x, \cdot) \in L(F; G)$ admits an adjoint $\lambda^*(x, \cdot) \in L(G^*; F^*)$, which induces an adjoint of the bilinear map as follows
\[
\lambda^*: E \times G^* \to F^* \quad \dpn{y, \lambda^*(x, \phi)}{F} = \dpn{\lambda(x, y), \phi}{G}
\]
Applying the above operation again yields a second adjoint
\[
\lambda^{**}: F^{**} \times G^* \to E^* \quad \dpn{x, \lambda^{**}(y, \phi)}{E} = \dpn{\lambda^*(x, \phi), y}{F^*}
\]
and finally, applying the adjoint operation a third time gives
\[
\Lambda_1 = \lambda^{***}: E^{**} \times F^{**} \to G^{**} \quad \dpn{\phi, \lambda^{***}(x, y)}{G^*} = \dpn{\lambda^{**}(y, \phi), x}{E^*}
\]
(1): Let $(x, y) \in E \times F$, then for each $\phi \in G^*$,
\[
\dpn{\phi, \Lambda_1(x, y)}{G^*} = \dpn{\lambda^{**}(y, \phi), x}{E^*} = \dpn{\lambda^*(x, \phi), y}{F^*} = \dpn{\lambda(x, y), \phi}{G}
\]
By the \hyperref[Hahn-Banach Theorem]{proposition:hahn-banach-utility}, $\Lambda_1$ is an extension of $\lambda$.
(2): Fix $x \in E$ and $\phi \in G^*$, then for each $y \in F^{**}$,
\begin{align*}
\dpn{\phi, \Lambda_1(x, y)}{G^*} &= \dpn{\lambda^{**}(y, \phi), x}{E^*} = \dpn{x, \lambda^{**}(y, \phi)}{E} \\
&= \dpn{\lambda^*(x, \phi), y}{F^*}
\end{align*}
Since $\lambda^*(x, \phi) \in F^*$, $\Lambda_1(x, \cdot)$ is weak*-continuous.
(3): Fix $y \in F^{**}$ and $\phi \in G^*$, then for each $x \in E^{**}$, $\dpn{\phi, \Lambda_1(x, y)}{G^*} = \dpn{\lambda^{**}(y, \phi), x}{E^*}$. Since $\lambda^{**}(y, \phi) \in E^*$, $\Lambda_1(\cdot, y)$ is weak*-continuous.
(Uniqueness): By \hyperref[Goldstine's Theorem]{corollary:weak-dense-unit-ball}, $E$ is weak*-dense in $E^{**}$, and $F$ is weak*-dense in $F^{**}$, so the extension is uniquely determined.
\end{proof}
\begin{proposition}
\label{proposition:arens-extension-continuous}
Let $E, F, G$ be normed vector spaces over $K \in \RC$, $\lambda \in L^2(E, F; G)$ be a continuous bilinear mapping, then $\Lambda_1, \Lambda_2 \in L^2(E^{**}, F^{**}; G^{**})$, where
\[
\norm{\lambda}_{L^2(E, F; G)} = \norm{\Lambda_1}_{L^2(E^{**}, F^{**}; G^{**})} = \norm{\Lambda_2}_{L^2(E^{**}, F^{**}; G^{**})}
\]
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
Assume without loss of generality that $\norm{\lambda}_{L^2(E, F; G)} = 1$. Fix $x \in \ol{B_{E}(0, 1)}$, then
\[
\Lambda_1(x, \ol{B_F(0, 1)}) = \lambda(x, \ol{B_F(0, 1)}) \subset \ol{B_{G^{**}}(0, 1)}
\]
Since for any $z \in G^{**}$, $\norm{z}_{G^{**}} = \sup_{\phi \in G^*, \norm{\phi}_{G^*} \le 1}\dpn{z, \phi}{G^*}$, the norm on $G^{**}$ is weak*-lower semicontinuous, and $\ol{B_{G^{**}}(0, 1)}$ is weak*-closed. By \hyperref[Goldstine's Theorem]{corollary:weak-dense-unit-ball}, $\ol{B_{F}(0, 1)}$ is weak*-dense in $\ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}$. As such, weak*-continuity of $\Lambda_1(x, \cdot)$ and \autoref{proposition:closure-of-image} implies that $\Lambda_1(x, \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}) \subset \ol{B_{G^{**}}(0, 1)}$ as well.
Now, fix $y \in \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}$, then $\Lambda_1(\ol{B_E(0, 1)}, y) \subset \ol{B_{G^{**}}(0, 1)}$. By \hyperref[Goldstine's Theorem]{corollary:weak-dense-unit-ball}, $\ol{B_{E}(0, 1)}$ is weak*-dense in $\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)}$. Thus the weak*-continuity of $\Lambda_1(\cdot, y)$ and \autoref{proposition:closure-of-image} implies that $\Lambda_1(\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)}, y) \subset \ol{B_{G^{**}}(0, 1)}$. Therefore
\[
\Lambda_1(\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}) \subset \ol{B_{G^{**}}(0, 1)}
\]
and $\norm{\lambda}_{L^2(E, F; G)} = \norm{\Lambda_1}_{L^2(E^{**}, F^{**}; G^{**})}$.
\end{proof}
\begin{definition}[Arens Regularity]
\label{definition:arens}
Let $E, F, G$ be normed vector spaces over $K \in \RC$, $\lambda \in L^2(E, F; G)$ be a continuous bilinear mapping, and $\Lambda_1, \Lambda_2: E^{**} \times F^{**} \to G^{**}$ be its first and second Arens extensions, respectively, then the following are equivalent:
\begin{enumerate}
\item $\Lambda_1 = \Lambda_2$.
\item There exists an extension $\Lambda: E^{**} \times F^{**} \to G^{**}$ of $\lambda$ that is separately weak*-continuous.
\item There exists an extension $\Lambda: E^{**} \times F^{**} \to G^{**}$ of $\lambda$ that is separately weak*-continuous when restricted to $\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}$.
\end{enumerate}
If the above holds, then $\lambda$ is an \textbf{Arens regular} bilinear map, and $\Lambda = \Lambda_1 = \Lambda_2$ is \textit{the} \textbf{Arens extension} of $\lambda$.
\end{definition}
\begin{proof}[Proof, {{\cite[Theorem 3.3]{ArensBilinear}}}. ]
(3) $\Rightarrow$ (1): By \hyperref[Goldstine's Theorem]{corollary:weak-dense-unit-ball}, $\ol{B_{E}(0, 1)}$ is weak*-dense in $\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)}$, and $\ol{B_{F}(0, 1)}$ is weak*-dense in $\ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}$. Thus the restrictions of $\Lambda_1$ and $\Lambda_2$ to $\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}$ are uniquely determined by the value of $\lambda$ on $\ol{B_{E}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F}(0, 1)}$, in the following sense:
\begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)]
\item $\Lambda_1|_{\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}}$ is the unique extension of $\lambda|_{\ol{B_{E}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F}(0, 1)}}$ such that
\begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*)]
\item For each $x \in \ol{B_E(0, 1)}$, $\Lambda_1(x, \cdot)$ is weak*-continuous.
\item For each $y \in \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}$, $\Lambda_1(\cdot, y)$ is weak*-continuous.
\end{enumerate}
\item $\Lambda_2|_{\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}}$ is the unique extension of $\lambda|_{\ol{B_{E}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F}(0, 1)}}$ such that
\begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*)]
\item For each $x \in \ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)}$, $\Lambda_2(x, \cdot)$ is weak*-continuous.
\item For each $y \in \ol{B_{F}(0, 1)}$, $\Lambda_2(\cdot, y)$ is weak*-continuous.
\end{enumerate}
\end{enumerate}
Since the given extension $\Lambda$ satisfies (i.a), (i.b), (ii.a), and (ii.b),
\[
\Lambda_1|_{\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}} = \Lambda = \Lambda_2|_{\ol{B_{E^{**}}(0, 1)} \times \ol{B_{F^{**}}(0, 1)}}
\]
As $\Lambda_1, \Lambda_2$ are bilinear, the above implies that $\Lambda_1 = \Lambda_2$.
\end{proof}

View File

@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@
\input{./linear.tex} \input{./linear.tex}
\input{./separable.tex} \input{./separable.tex}
\input{./multilinear.tex} \input{./multilinear.tex}
\input{./arens.tex}
\input{./hilbert.tex} \input{./hilbert.tex}
\input{./compact.tex} \input{./compact.tex}
\input{./ap.tex} \input{./ap.tex}

View File

@@ -117,6 +117,51 @@ Despite not covering the full dual space, the bounded Borel functions still form
(2) $\Rightarrow$ (1): By the \hyperref[Dominated Convergence Theorem]{theorem:dct-bochner-vector}. (2) $\Rightarrow$ (1): By the \hyperref[Dominated Convergence Theorem]{theorem:dct-bochner-vector}.
\end{proof} \end{proof}
The following is an explicit construction of what should be the Arens product on $C(X; \complex)^{**}$ thanks to the above description of $M_R(X; \complex)$ and its dual.
\begin{proposition}
\label{proposition:measures-dual-algebra}
Let $X$ be a compact Hausdorff space, $J: C(X; \complex) \to C(X; \complex)^{**}$ be the natural embedding, and $B$ be the closed unit ball of $C(X; \complex)^{**}$, then
\begin{enumerate}
\item There exists a unique weak*-continuous involution $C(X; \complex)^{**}$ such that $J(f^*) = J(f)^*$ for all $f \in C(X; \complex)$, given by
\[
C(X; \complex)^{**} \to C(X; \complex)^{**} \quad \dpn{\mu, \phi^*}{C(X; \complex)^*} = \ol{\dpn{\mu, \phi}{C(X; \complex)^*}}
\]
\item There exists a unique seperately weak*-continuous bilinear map on $C(X; \complex)^{**}$ such that $J(fg) = J(f)J(g)$ for all $f, g \in C(X; \complex)$.
\item $C(X; \complex)^{**}$ equipped with the above involution and product is a commutative unital $C^*$-algebra.
\end{enumerate}
\end{proposition}
\begin{proof}
It is sufficient to construct the maps in (1) and (2). Let $\seqi{\mu}$ be a maximal mutually singular family of Radon measures on $X$. Using \autoref{theorem:hilbert-measures-dual} and the \hyperref[Riesz Representation Theorem]{theorem:riesz-radon-c0}, identify
\[
C(X; \complex)^{*} = M_R(X; \complex) = [l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)] \quad C(X; \complex)^{**} = [l^\infty(I); L^\infty(\mu_i; \complex)]
\]
Under the above, $C(X; \complex)$ may be identified as the diagonal
\[
\bracsn{f \in C(X; \complex)^I|f_i = f_j \forall i, j \in I} \subset [l^\infty(I); L^\infty(\mu_i; \complex)]
\]
which is weak*-dense in $[l^\infty(I); L^\infty(\mu_i; \complex)]$ by \hyperref[Goldstine's Theorem]{corollary:weak-dense-unit-ball}.
(1): For each $g \in [l^\infty(I); L^\infty(\mu_i; \complex)]$, let $g^* = \ol g$. For any $\mu \in [l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)]$,
\[
\dpn{\mu, g^*}{[l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)]} = \dpn{f, \ol g}{[l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)]} = \ol{\dpn{f, g}{[l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)]}}
\]
so the conjugation map is weak*-continuous.
(2): Let $f, g \in [l^\infty(I); L^\infty(\mu_i; \complex)]$ and $\mu \in [l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)]$,
\[
\dpn{\mu, fg}{[l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)]} = \dpn{f\mu, g}{[l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)]} = \dpn{g\mu, f}{[l^1(I); L^1(\mu_i; \complex)]}
\]
so the composition map is separately weak*-continuous.
(3): $[l^\infty(I); L^\infty(\mu_i; \complex)]$ is a commutative unital $C^*$-algebra.
\end{proof}
\begin{proposition} \begin{proposition}
\label{proposition:space-of-measures-extreme-points} \label{proposition:space-of-measures-extreme-points}
Let $X$ be an LCH space and $\cm \subset \overline{B_{M_R(X; \complex)}(0, 1)}$ be a compact convex set such that: Let $X$ be an LCH space and $\cm \subset \overline{B_{M_R(X; \complex)}(0, 1)}$ be a compact convex set such that:

19
src/op/vn/fc.tex Normal file
View File

@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
\section{The Borel Functional Calculus}
\label{section:borel-functional-calculus}
\begin{definition}[Borel Functional Calculus]
\label{definition:borel-functional-calculus}
Let $H$ be a complex Hilbert space, $A \subset B(H)$ be a von Neumann algebra, and $x \in A$ be normal, then there exists a unique continuous unital *-homomorphism
\[
C(\sigma_A(x); \complex)^{**} \to A[x] \quad f \mapsto f(x)
\]
such that:
\begin{enumerate}
\item $\one(x) = 1_A$, $\text{Id}(x) = x$, and $\overline{\text{Id}}(x) = x^*$.
\item The mapping $f \mapsto f(x)$ is continuous from the weak* topology on $C(\sigma_A(x); \complex)^{**}$ to the strong operator topology on $B(H)$.
\end{enumerate}
\end{definition}
\begin{proof}
Since the \autoref{definition:continuous-functional-calculus}
\end{proof}